Capability Pattern: 8.11 Confidence in the use of software tools
This practice details the tasks required to be carried out to qualify software tools. Even if the tool has been prequalified by a tool vendor the organization must confirm the validity of the tool confidence level or qualification, prior to the software tool being used for the development of safety related item or element.
Work Breakdown Structure
Purpose
To ensure that the software tools employed on a safety related project are suitable to be used to tailor the activities or tasks required by ISO 26262. This task provides the criteria to evaluate the required level of confidence in a tool and means for the qualification of the software tool.
Description

A software tool used in the development of a system, its software or hardware elements, can support or enable a tailoring of the safety-lifecycle, by the tailoring of the activities and tasks required by ISO 26262. In such cases confidence is needed that the software tool effectively achieves the following goals:

a) the risk of systematic faults in the developed product due to malfunctions of the software tool leading to erroneous outputs is minimized, and

b) the development process is adequate with respect to compliance with ISO 26262, if activities or tasks required by ISO 26262 rely on the correct functioning of the software tool used.

Software tools  this instance are not limited to tools for creating the underlying SW used in the item or element but any SW tool that is employed as part of the development process for a safety related item or element. Typical examples are compilers, requirements management tools (Rational DOORS has been qualified by the tUV) and test generation tools. Code generation tools do not need to be qualified when used in conjunction with a qualified test tools as the test tool should find any errors that have been introduced by the code generation tool. A good example of this is using Rational Rhapsody for code generation in combination with the Rational Rhapsody Test Conductor (which is qualified by TUV).

To determine the required level of confidence in a software tool used within development the following criteria are evaluated:

The possibility that the malfunctioning software tool and its corresponding erroneous output can introduce or fail to detect errors in a safety-related item or element being developed, and

The confidence in preventing or detecting such errors in its corresponding output.

To evaluate the confidence in prevention or detection measures, measures internal to the software tool (e.g. monitoring) as well as measures external to the software tool (e.g. guidelines, tests, reviews) implemented in the development process of the safety-related item or element are considered and can be assessed.

If indicated by the determined tool confidence level, then appropriate qualification methods are applied to comply with both this tool confidence level and the maximum ASIL of all the safety requirements allocated to the item or element that is to be developed using the software tool. Otherwise there is no need to apply such qualification methods.

Workflow

Activity diagram: 8.11 Confidence in the use of software tools Evaluation of SW tool Determine applicable qualification methods Evaluation of the SW tool development process Plan SW tool qualification Validate the SW tool Confirmation Review of the Qualification of the Software Tool Confirm the validity of predetermined TCL or Qualification Qualify based upon increased confidence from use Check SW tool development in compliance with a safety standard Develop the Software Tool Criteria Report

Activity detail diagram: 8.11 Confidence in the use of software tools Safety Engineer Evaluation of SW tool Determine applicable qualification methods Evaluation of the SW tool development process Validate the SW tool Qualify based upon increased confidence from use Check SW tool development in compliance with a safety standard Develop the Software Tool Criteria Report Safety Engineer Tool Specialist Evaluation of SW tool Determine applicable qualification methods Plan SW tool qualification Confirm the validity of predetermined TCL or Qualification Qualify based upon increased confidence from use Tool Specialist Safety Manager Plan SW tool qualification Confirm the validity of predetermined TCL or Qualification Develop the Software Tool Criteria Report Safety Manager Independent Safety Auditor Confirmation Review of the Qualification of the Software Tool Independent Safety Auditor Pre-determined maximum ASIL Safety plan Evaluation of SW tool Software tool classification analysis Evaluation of SW tool Software tool classification analysis Determine applicable qualification methods Software tool qualification plan Determine applicable qualification methods Software tool classification analysis Software tool qualification plan Evaluation of the SW tool development process Software tool qualification report Evaluation of the SW tool development process Software tool classification analysis Software tool qualification report Software tool documentation Validate the SW tool Software tool qualification report Validate the SW tool Software tool qualification plan Software tool classification analysis Qualify based upon increased confidence from use Software tool qualification report Qualify based upon increased confidence from use Software tool classification analysis Software tool qualification plan Check SW tool development in compliance with a safety standard Software tool development assessment report Check SW tool development in compliance with a safety standard Software tool classification analysis Software tool qualification plan Software tool qualification report Develop the Software Tool Criteria Report Software Tool Criteria evaluation report Develop the Software Tool Criteria Report Pre-determined maximum ASIL Safety plan Evaluation of SW tool Software tool classification analysis Evaluation of SW tool Software tool classification analysis Determine applicable qualification methods Software tool qualification plan Determine applicable qualification methods Safety plan Plan SW tool qualification Software tool qualification plan Plan SW tool qualification Software tool classification analysis Software tool qualification report Confirm the validity of predetermined TCL or Qualification Software tool qualification report Confirm the validity of predetermined TCL or Qualification Software tool qualification plan Software tool classification analysis Qualify based upon increased confidence from use Software tool qualification report Qualify based upon increased confidence from use Safety plan Plan SW tool qualification Software tool qualification plan Plan SW tool qualification Software tool classification analysis Software tool qualification report Confirm the validity of predetermined TCL or Qualification Software tool qualification report Confirm the validity of predetermined TCL or Qualification Software tool classification analysis Software tool qualification plan Software tool qualification report Develop the Software Tool Criteria Report Software Tool Criteria evaluation report Develop the Software Tool Criteria Report Environment and software tool constraints Pre-determined maximum ASIL Software tool classification analysis Confirmation Review of the Qualification of the Software Tool
Work Breakdown